When Sleep Coaching Isn't Working: Understanding the Roadblocks

Listen to the Podcast Here!

Sleep coaching can be a game-changer for many families, offering the promise of better rest for both parents and children. Yet, despite your best efforts, you might still find yourself facing a frustrating roadblock: sleep coaching just isn’t working for your family. So why is that?

On the latest episode of the Birth and Baby Podcast, we dive deep into this issue. Whether you're following a method like the Ferber method or trying a more gentle approach like the Sleep Lady Shuffle, roadblocks can arise. It’s important to remember that you're not alone in this journey, and there are many reasons sleep coaching may not yield the results you expected.

Here are some common reasons:

1. Following Your Child, Not Establishing a Routine
   One of the biggest challenges parents face is continuing to follow their child's cues without transitioning to a routine as they grow. As newborns, it’s essential to respond to their needs, but over time, establishing routines can help babies settle more easily. Regular rhythms and routines help your baby understand when it’s time to sleep. As we discussed in the podcast, "At some point, we need to realize that babies thrive on some predictability." So, while following cues is important, incorporating routines will create structure and consistency.

2. Accidental Parenting & Mixed Messages
   In the podcast, we referred to accidental parenting as a cycle many parents unknowingly fall into. "We do whatever works for today," but that can create mixed messages for your child. When our responses to sleep challenges vary, children can get confused, which makes it harder for them to understand sleep expectations. Consistency is key here.

3. Not Reading Your Child's Cues
   Another common pitfall is not recognizing or misinterpreting your child's individual sleep cues. Not every child needs the same amount of awake time before sleep, and some children may show more subtle signs of tiredness, especially as they grow older and become more interested in the world around them. In the podcast, we emphasized how tuning into your child’s unique needs can prevent overtiredness. Paying attention to signs like eye-rubbing or fussiness at certain times of the day can help you get ahead of sleep problems.

4. Underestimating Constant Change
   This is probably one of the hardest aspects of sleep coaching. Just when you feel like you’ve finally nailed down a routine, your baby changes. "What worked last week might not work this week, and what didn’t work last week could be the perfect solution today," as we discussed. Your baby is developing quickly, and so are their sleep needs. Be prepared to adapt, especially during growth spurts, teething, or sleep regressions.

5. Seeking an Easy Fix
   There is no magic bullet when it comes to sleep coaching. It requires time, patience, and consistency. Expecting overnight success will often lead to frustration. Celebrate the small wins, like a longer nap or fewer night wakeups, and remember that progress is gradual.

6. Lack of Commitment
   As we mentioned in the podcast, consistency is crucial in sleep coaching. When you start a sleep coaching plan, it’s important to commit for at least three to five nights. "If you're not fully committed, it won't work," because inconsistency will confuse your baby, leading to more sleep struggles.

7. Mismatched Methods
   Not all sleep coaching techniques work for every child or every family. "Sleep coaching is about finding a method that resonates with your family and your baby," so if a method feels off, it might be time to explore other options. Each child has unique needs, and it's essential to find an approach that feels right for your family.

8. No Need for Fixing
   Perhaps there’s nothing to fix. If your current sleep situation is manageable and everyone is relatively well-rested, you might not need to make changes. In our episode, we discussed how co-sleeping or nursing through the night isn’t inherently a problem unless it’s impacting your well-being.

9. Unrealistic Expectations
   Progress may take weeks, not days. We stressed in the podcast that while many families see improvements within three to five nights, true consistency and routine can take several weeks to fully establish. Parenting—and sleep coaching—is a marathon, not a sprint.

If you find yourself struggling with sleep coaching, it's essential to identify the underlying factors contributing to the challenge. By addressing these roadblocks and adjusting your approach accordingly, you can work towards healthier sleep habits for your family. Remember, sleep coaching is a journey, and every child is different. With patience, persistence, and the right support, you’ll find the sleep solution that works for your family.

And if you need support on this journey, I’m here to guide you with compassion and personalized solutions. You’ve got this!